Valentine
Candi Rose (EnnVee)
A good combination of costume pieces and color applications. My only real complaint is that your screenshots are so tiny in comparison to the background color.
All Bled Out (Zekiran_Immortal)
Judging by the ears and face, I'm going with the idea that this is a vampire of some sort. All of the elements and colors work well together. This would make an excellent Necro/Pain MM.
Luv Muffin (Angel_Red)
Everything's working well here - the goofy smile, the hair, even the tux and kilt combo works until you get to the wrapped boots. I would try something else that goes better with the tux and the kilt. Perhaps this guy is a Scottish Don Juan?
Romeo (KAKTOS)
The stick idea is great! The vest/jacket and eyewear reminds me of Animal Man a little, but that's not a bad thing. I like your choice of patterns and overall color usage. I might recommend darkening up the heart on his chest, though. It doesn't really pop as much as I would think a chest emblem should.
Unchained Heart (Vulcanite)
Nice use of the hearts pattern. Given the wings and archery aspect of the character, would she be a Cupid-like character?
Hart of Hearts (Halloween_Jack)
I like that you've played with the words in naming the character. The overall use and distribution of colors works well. I especially like the shield. As a matter of fact, I'd try and mimic that look on the chest, or at least make the hart emblem on the chest match the one on the shield.
Heart Breaker (BlackberryThorn)
Looks like we have a bit of harpy action here. I like it. Nice use of the organic legs and using color to alter their appearance.
Disheartened (Chyll)
This is a fairly simple design, but it works well. Your choice of hood leads me to think of this character as a night-stalking thief or assassin of some sort. If that is the case, I recommend swapping your color scheme here so that the chest, arms and legs are a predominantly darker color. I would then make the gloves and boots the lighter pink color. Or something like this. It's quick and incomplete, but it gives the general impression.
Luvum Bear (Barron_)
This is a ridiculously cute idea for a villain. Everything you've done here helps emphasize the Care Bear nature of this character. Nice job.
Venema (Starwind)
I wish I had those helmets at my disposal. First, why black skin? I can understand why you'd want this particular costume piece since it gives you an impression of criss-crossing webs. I have to hand it to you. Your use of the palette is so subtle, that I have to stop and do a "Where's Waldo?" to find them.
Peppermint Bachelor (Gaspard)
This is a scary lookin' dude! Is he running loose in Atlas? I like the candy cane striping you've got on his face and tie. That grimace and axe must make it difficult for him to get a date, though. He must really like bachelorhood.
Heart-Break (Trickshooter)
This is a freaky looking chick stamped with the Trickshooter trademark star. I would think that the color palette combined with that skin color would become an eyesore, but it seems to work in some strange way.
Lovebird (ArticPathos)
This is an interesting design combining the fishnets with the knee-high socks. Everything works well here. I'm not a fan of the abrupt change in color for the ends of the sleeves, and would probably just make them match the rest of the arm, but that's a personal preference.
Captain Codpiece (Genkio)
Oh dear. The man's furrier than Ron Jeremy! Despite the nightmare-inducing codpiece, this Chippendale's reject makes excellent use of the color palette. I need to scrub my brain now...
Nurse Heartfelt (ToollooT)
I get the feeling that she's not really a certified nurse, is she? Regardless of her actual profession, she's showcasing a good, contrasting pattern of colors. Good job making the heart emblem stand out.
And the winner is...All Bled Out!
Send me a PM with your head sketch request and a link to reference! (Remember it's a head sketch, so far away shots won't be helpful.)